Gut Rumbles
 

August 27, 2003

odds and ends

* When I wrote about harmony vocals, I am surprised that more people didn't mention any bands from the 50's, such as Danny and the Juniors ("At the Hop") and some of the other really good stoop-singing harmonizers.

* The bionic Roscoe will remain a topic for blog-fodder until I am totally comfortable with the new me.

* That buttwipe michael Fumento really derailed my "kindler, gentler Acidman" plan. I went pretty ballistic, just like the good old days in response to his comment. Maybe I'm not cut out for the kindler, gentler thing. Fumento is a good writer but an ego-consumed asshole just the same. I calls 'em like I sees 'em.

* Music posts seem to get a lot of comments. I own seven guitars, two banjos, one mandolin, an autoharp, five harmonicas, an electric keyboard and a lap-steel. Music is an important part of my life.

I heard that Rolling Stone just announced the results of a poll of the 100 best guitarists of all time. Jimi Hendrix was #1.

Here are MY top ten:

1) Chet Atkins

2) Mark Knopfler

3) Jimi Hendrix

4) Eric Clapton

5) Ricky Skaggs

6) Andre Segovia

7) James Taylor (because NOBODY ELSE plays the way he does)

8) Doc Watson

9) Dwayne Allman

10) Leo Kottke

Yeah, I include acoustic guitar players on my list because playing acoustic is more difficult than playing electric. Give me a good pedal on my Fender and I can make drunken shit sound good. I can't do that on my Martin.

Hey! I have an idea for a POLL!!!

Who do YOU believe are the TOP TEN GUITAR PLAYERS OF ALL TIME?

Yes, the Muse is with me tonight.

Comments

Top Guitarists

Your list is really good. Let me add a few others:

Charlie Christian
Jim Hall
Pat Metheny
David Bromberg
Wes Montgomery
Doc Watson
B.B. King
Robert Johnson
Chuck Berry
Jerry Garcia

I know I'm leaving some favorites out. Oh Well.

Posted by: chris on August 27, 2003 05:06 PM

Can't leave out Eric Johnson.

Oh....

Well, I guess you can -- you did.

Posted by: Russ on August 27, 2003 05:40 PM

In no particular order:

Jimi Hendrix
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Duane Allman
Dave Navarro (Jane's Addiciton)
Willie Nelson
Kim Thayill (Soundgarden)
Rich Brotherton (Robert Earl Keen)
Jónsi Birgisson (Sigur Rós)
Dimebag Darrell (Pantera)
Adam Jones (Tool)

Yeah, so most of those are on the heavier side of music. This makes sense given that I listen to a lot of that type of music. Also, I like guys that play varied textures, not just straight licks.

Posted by: K.C. on August 27, 2003 05:54 PM

I would put Willie in the top ten as a stylist, but NOT as a really good guitar player.

But that's my opinion. I could be wrong.

Posted by: Acidman on August 27, 2003 06:20 PM

I can't give you ten at the moment, but definitely Jimi, Leo Kottke - he really wowed me in concert, Santana, Clapton, Paige, and BB King, Stevie Ray Vaughan. I'm missing something with Chuck Berry..I have to go back and listen to something.

Also I seen a 10 year old boy on TV a few months ago that played like Hendrix...he was good enough he brought me in from the other room to see who was playing. This kid has already been on a live stage with Santana..he gave me goose bumps. He might be the one to beat them all...and damn I can't remember his name.

Posted by: Dawn on August 27, 2003 06:32 PM

Here's my ten in no particular order:

1. Jimi Hendrix
2. Eric Clapton
3. Duane Allman
4. Al DiMeola
5. Jimmy Page
6. Bo Diddley
7. Chet Atkins
8. Pat Metheny
9. Stevie Ray Vaughn
10. Jerry Garcia

Posted by: Ralph Gizzip on August 27, 2003 07:01 PM

1. Chet Atkins
2. Jimi Hendrix
3. Eric Clapton
4. Steve Earle
5. BB King
6. Dave Evans (U2)
7. Chuck Berry
8. Stevie Ray Vaughn
9. Eddie Van Halen
10. John Williams (Classical)

... cramming it into ten is rather tough.

Posted by: Mr. Lion on August 27, 2003 07:27 PM

John Williams
Andres Segovia
Mark Knopfler
Manitas des Platas
Carlos Montoya
Monte Dunn
Chet Atkins
Wes Montgomery
Doc Watson
Tony Rice
This really isn't fair, because there's not enough room until I get on the list, but I've heard all of these guys live, and picked with three of them. It was a humbling experience, to say the least. The skill and concentration, the intensity and feeling are a reward for the listener as well as the artist. They are special indeed.

Posted by: bob in the hills on August 27, 2003 07:32 PM

I'd have to say they fall somewhat like this. I'm trying to rate them as far as changing the artform.

1. Robert Johnson
2. Jimi Hendrix
3. Johnny Greenwood (Radiohead)
4. John Squire (The Stone Roses)
5. Stevie Ray Vaughn
6. Jimmy Page (Led Zeppelin)
7. John Frusciante (Red Hot Chili Peppers)
8. Tom Morello (RATM & Audioslave)
9. George Harrison (The Beatles)
10. Ry Cooder

Posted by: Gdub on August 27, 2003 07:42 PM

George Harrison as always been under-rated as guitar player, just as Ringo Starr was under-rated as a drummer. They both were damn good.

Posted by: Acidman on August 27, 2003 07:49 PM

And most people who voted for Robert Johnson never heard him play. Not even on those grainy tapes I've listened to.

Posted by: Acidman on August 27, 2003 07:51 PM

Muddy Waters was a LOT better than Robert Johnson. Bilnd Lemon wasn't taking second place, either.

Posted by: Acidman on August 27, 2003 07:53 PM

You might be right with Robert Johnson. But with him the guitar playing has to be taken with the whole package: the singing, the lyrics, and the mystique. Making a deal with the devil to play like that has got to count for something.

Posted by: chris on August 27, 2003 07:58 PM

True, Willie's not the most blessed guy in terms of technical talent; however, his playing is almost instantly recognizable. In my book, that's worth a hell of a lot.

Posted by: K.C. on August 27, 2003 08:15 PM

Paul McCartney.

What? A bass isn't a guitar? Listen, McCartney is the best damned bassist there ever was. His bass lines are just as tuneful as the melodies. Every Beatles song has such a distinctive bassline that you can tell which song it is from that alone. How many other bands could make the same claim? No matter who you pick for an all-star band, they're gonna need a bassist, and Paul wins that contest, hands down.

Posted by: Normal Ph Man on August 27, 2003 08:46 PM

Knopfler? NFW.
Nobody puts Jeff Beck on? No Keith Richards?

Posted by: Patrick on August 27, 2003 10:15 PM

Here are MY top ten:
1) Jimi Hendrix
2) Tony Rice
3) Chet Atkins
4) Steven Stills
5) Jimmy Page
6) Eric Clapton
7) Mark Knopfler
8) Doc Watson
9) Junior Brown
10) Stevie Ray Vaughn

Posted by: Willy on August 27, 2003 10:32 PM

Julian Bream
Frank Zappa
Jimmy Page
Jimi Hendrix
Leo Kottke
Lindsey Buckingham
Peter Green
Steve Vai
From Blue Oyster Cult (Eric..?)
Mark Knopfler

Posted by: The Breakfast Troll on August 27, 2003 10:56 PM

Sticking only to people I've heard enough of to make a judgement...I simply haven't heard the old blues players enough to figure out where they would be, so they're disqualified from my list.

1 Hendrix
2 Jimmy Page
3 Lindsey Buckingham (Fleetwood Mac)
4 Mark Knopfler (yes F'in way. You have to listen to more than just their singles before you try and dis him, Patrick.)
5 Eddie van Halen
6 Stevie Ray Vaughn
7 Martin Barre (Jethro Tull)
8 Rick Nielsen (Cheap Trick)
9 Roger McGuinn (The Byrds)
10 Ted Nugent

And ten guys who would never make it on my list of great players, but I love to listen to their music:

Richie Blackmore
Sammy Hagar
Joe Walsh
Angus Young
Tony Iommi
Joe Perry
Keith Richards
Dave Davies
Tom Petty
Alex Lifeson


Posted by: Steve Sandvik on August 27, 2003 11:15 PM

Have to break it down by genre. You can't compare John Williams and Yngwie Malmsteen, fer chrissakes.


Classical:
- John Williams
- Segovia
- Julian Bream
- Jan Akkerman

Acoustic:
- Earl Klugh
- Steven Stills
- Leo Kotke
- Shawn Phillips
- Jose Feliciano
- Ry Cooder


Blues:
- Muddy
- Jimmy Page
- Clapton
- B.B. King
- Jeff Beck
- Peter Green (F. Mac)
- SRV
- Eric Johnson
- Joe Runde
- Gary Moore

Rock:
- Hendrix
- Yngwie Malmsteen
- Eddie Van Halen
- Terry Kath (Chicago)
- Tony Iommi (Sabbath)
- Martin Barre (Tull)
- Michael Schenker
- Trevor Rabin (Yes)
- Randy Rhoades
- Steve Morse
- Richie Blackmore (Deep Purple)

Jazz:
- Al DiMeola
- Johnny Fourie
- John McLaughlin
- Larry Coryell

Posted by: Kim du Toit on August 27, 2003 11:30 PM

Chet Atkins
Les Paul
Stevie Ray Vaughn
Mark Knopfler
Jerry Garcia
(Knopfler and Garcia are masters at knowing when NOT to play and laying it in just damned right.)
Clapton
Ry Cooder
Brian Setzer
Tony Mottola
Eddie Van Halen

Posted by: Parkway Rest Stop on August 27, 2003 11:33 PM

Some off-the-wall picks:

Dickie Betts
Jorma Kaukonen
Billy Byrd
Les Paul
Django Reinhardt
Tony Mottola
Charlie Byrd
Paul Prestopino

Posted by: rivlax on August 27, 2003 11:38 PM

Du Toit's got a point. Perhaps we should specify genre? I mean, what the hell am I doing comparing Vaughn and Birgisson? Apples and oranges. . .

Posted by: K.C. on August 28, 2003 01:15 AM

I agree with all the lists. However, Steve Morse is the Greatest! What? Don’t believe me? I posted a couple of MP3s for your listening enjoyment. (click my link below) By the way, I didn’t see Pete Towsend on anyone’s list.

Posted by: Dax Montana on August 28, 2003 03:50 AM

I've seen all of these people live.
King Crimson's Robert Fripp. He is the best. His fingers fly so fast; you have no idea what he's doing. The same for his bass player Trey Gunn. Ever see a man play two ten string basses at once? (actually it's a touch guitar)
George Lynch (Dokken, Lynch Mob) is underrated because of the music. He is fantastic live.
Buddy Guy can play anything, though I didn't like the show when I last saw him.
Knopfler is easily one of the best. I wouldn't include Garcia, but he was very good. You have to listen to more than just their singles, as said above.
Including others I've seen: Eddie, SRV, Buck Dharma (Donald Roeser) from Blue Oyster Cult (not Eric Bloom), Michael Schenker, Slash, J. Geils, Tom Scholz (everyone gives him shit, and it's mostly his ego, but he can still play), David Gilmour.

And who I haven't seen (and for most never will) Jimi, Clapton, Duane Allman, Randy Rhodes, Gary Moore, Pete Townshend.

I’ve left off other obvious ones, because I don’t know them well enough. Most probably are better than what I have.

Posted by: CMNF on August 28, 2003 08:34 AM

Bejus! No one mentioned Rev. Gary Davis or Merle Travis?

Quoting Chet Atkins: "If it wasn't for Merle Travis, I'd still be looking at the back end of a mule."

Roy Buchanon's "Drowning on Dry Land" is why I started playing guitar.

For stylists, try Mississippi John Hurt.

Posted by: lpdbw on August 28, 2003 11:09 AM

Norman Blake. How can you nominate Tony Rice and not even mention Norman Blake?

Posted by: Gramps on August 28, 2003 11:27 AM

Norman Blake. Several people mentioned Tony Rice. Rice is good, but Blake is much better. In my opinion the best accoustic guitarist ever.

Posted by: Gramps on August 28, 2003 11:29 AM

I cannot believe no one has mentioned Joe Satriani or Steve Vai.

Heathens.

Posted by: Guy Montag on August 28, 2003 11:32 PM

So i guess Django Reinhart is just so much chopped liver, after all! Jeez.

Posted by: pril on August 29, 2003 10:17 AM

I don't disagree with any picker that has been mentioned, but there are some names that have been left out:

Vince Gill
Jerry Reed
Glen Campbell
Toy Caldwell (Marshall Tucker Band)
Johnny Winter
Bruce Osburn (toured with Porter Waggoner)
Robert Cray

Posted by: Gene K on August 30, 2003 01:37 PM

These are in no particular order, but are all my favorite g men, for their own special styles and personalities.

1. Chet Atkins
2. Stevie Ray Vaughn / Freddie King
3. George Benson
4. Chris Whitley
5. Jake E Lee / Vivian Campbell
6. Eddie van Halen
7. Steve Vai
8. Nuno Bettoncourt
9. James Taylor / Jim Croche
10. Dave Mustaine / Kerry King

Posted by: Pete on September 1, 2003 03:41 AM

Obviously rolling stone has got it wrong, the best guitarist which should be number 1 is

Tom Morello (RATM & Audioslave)

he can make some of the weirdest sounds you would ever hear and uses no samplers or pre recordings. In my eye's he's truly the best.

Posted by: Da EMCEE on November 21, 2003 07:02 AM

Bob in the Hills

Did you play with Monte Dunn?? If you did or know where to get in touch with him...let me know pls.

Thanks for including such a great player in the list. No one else did!!

Ray

Posted by: Ray on December 29, 2003 02:57 PM

Some of the greatest are also relatively unknown.
Choosing the top ten greatest guitarists is subjective and difficult.
The greatest in this case is not determined by the same criteria as one would rate the fastest athlete.
My favourites/"greatest"
1) Jeff Beck
2) Django Reinhardt
3) Paco de Lucia
4) Jimi Hendrix
5) Ollie Halsall (Patto, Boxer, Tempest)
6) Tommy Bolin
7) Larry Coryell
8) Al de Meola
9) Joe Pass
10) John Etheridge (Daryll Way's Wolf, Soft Machine)

Other notewothy players
Mikkel Nordso (fusion guitarist - Denmark)
John Goodsall (Brand X)
Paul Gilbert
Joe Satriani
Johnny Winter
Lenny Breau

CRIMINALISE DRUM PROGRAMMING!!!!!

Adios

Posted by: Vivian Bannatyne on March 26, 2004 07:52 AM
Post a comment